Web Analytics

Why Is Investing So Hard?

Conceptually, investing is simple.

Every book says the same thing: buy broad exposure to the global market, keep costs low, reinvest, and stay invested.

Yet when I meet a new client, I often hear: “I’ve never had much luck with investing.”

There must be a reason that most investors don’t capture the returns of the markets they invest in.

This is the paradox at the heart of personal finance: the strategy is easy; the behaviour is hard.

The Theory vs. The Reality

On paper it’s straightforward: pick an index fund, automate the contributions, hold for twenty or thirty years, avoid the news. Done.

But humans are not spreadsheets, we are story-driven, emotionally reactive, loss-averse creatures living with an uncertain future.

So when the market falls 30% in a single year, as it did in 2008 and again in March 2020, the elegant simplicity of “just hold” collides with the primal survival instinct that yelling: “Do something. Get out. Protect yourself.”

The DALBAR Quantitative Analysis of Investor Behaviour study consistently shows that individual investors dramatically underperform the very funds they invest in, not because the funds perform badly, but because humans buy high and sell low.

Over thirty years, that behavioural gap averages between 3% and 5% per year, purely due to poorly timing.

This isn’t a lack of intelligence, it's biology.

Our Instincts Work Everywhere… Except Here

In most areas of life, our instincts are an advantage.

If you feel danger, you step away.
If something seems too good to be true, you hesitate.
If a decision feels wrong, you pause.

I have two friends who served in Afghanistan who talk about their “spider senses” going off seconds before something bad happened.

Those instincts help us avoid bad relationships, risky situations and questionable opportunities.

But investing flips this idea on its head.

When the markets boom and everyone seems to be making easy money, your gut whispers, “You’re missing out.”

Yet that’s usually when future returns are weakest.

When the market feels awful and the headlines scream doom, your gut shouts, “Sell and survive.”

Yet that’s usually when future returns are their highest.

To be a successful investor, you often have to do the very opposite of what your instincts demand.

Why Vanguard Say Advisers Add Around 3%

Vanguard Adviser Alpha study suggests that a good financial adviser can add about 3% per year in net returns, not from picking better funds but from preventing bad decisions.

Around half that value comes from behavioural coaching—helping clients avoid panic selling, market timing, performance chasing, and reactive allocation changes.

When the world feels uncertain, advisers act as emotional stabilisers: widening time horizons, reframing volatility, and re-anchoring behaviour to long-term discipline.

In other words, the best advisers aren’t just managing portfolios, they are managing patience, discomfort, and perspective.

The Real Work of Successful Investors

Ultimately, the hardest work in investing isn’t knowing what to do; it is doing it, repeatedly, especially when it feels uncomfortable.

To invest successfully is to:

  • tolerate discomfort
  • embrace uncertainty
  • maintain discipline
  • accept volatility
  • trust compounding
  • and let time do the lifting

This is not an absence of emotion, it is the mastering of it.

A Positive Note: Discipline Is a Superpower You Can Build

The encouraging truth is that successful investing doesn’t require forecasting ability, economic genius, or inside information.

It requires temperament.

And temperament is trainable.

Many great investors aren’t the smartest in the room, they are the calmest.

The  market ultimately rewards patience, rationality, and discipline.

And while that is hard, it is also empowering because it means the primary driver of investment success is not something outside of your control.

It is internal, learnable, and within reach.

More Blog Posts

Copy here introducing the client stories section and examples of testimonials

We have a plan

By its very nature, financial planning is just that: planning. We can’t know what will happen, so we make sure that even if the worst should take place, you’re protected. We find out when we meet you, what your capacity for loss is, and what your lifetime goals are.
Learn More

Zooming into 2021

I’m sure you’re familiar with the Benjamin Franklin quote: “In this world nothing can be said to be certain, except death and taxes.” But what about change? If this year has taught us anything it’s that change just as certain.
Learn More

How safe is my money?

The recent banking crisis, which started with Silicon Valley Bank (SVP) and may not yet have run its course, has made several of our clients ask “How safe is my money?”
Learn More